Guides

The hardest 24 puzzles

In the 24 game you combine four numbers with + − × ÷ to make exactly 24. Most sets fall to a factor pair like 3 × 8 or 4 × 6. A handful do not: every route through whole numbers fails, and the only way to 24 passes through a fraction. These are the puzzles that stump strong players — and once you know the two tricks behind them, you can solve all of them.

How we know there are exactly 16

We ran BRINXO's Number Forge solver over every set of four numbers from 1 to 13 — the values of a deck of cards. There are 1,820 different sets (order does not matter, repeats allowed). 1,362 can make 24; 458 cannot. Of the solvable ones, exactly 16 have no solution that stays in whole numbers at every step. The solver works with exact fractions, so nothing is missed by rounding. You can check any set yourself with the 24 solver.

Trick 1: divide by a small fraction

Dividing by ½ doubles a number; dividing by ¼ multiplies it by four. So if you can build a small fraction from three of the numbers, the fourth can be "blown up" to 24. Look for a number that is 24 divided by a whole number — 6 (24 ÷ 4), 8 (24 ÷ 3), 12 (24 ÷ 2), 4 (24 ÷ 6) — then try to make that whole number's reciprocal.

Notice the pattern inside the brackets: a whole number minus a fraction close to it leaves a tiny remainder. 1 − ¾, 3 − 2½, 3 − 2⅔: each is the reciprocal you need.

Trick 2: multiply by a mixed number

The other family works the opposite way. If one number, n, is a factor of 24 "with a leftover", you can make 24 ÷ n as a mixed number — a whole number plus or minus a fraction with n in the denominator — and multiply back by n.

The signal is a pair (5 and 5, 7 and 7, 11 and 11, 13 and 13) or a number that does not divide 24 at all. When 24 ÷ n is not a whole number, write it as a mixed number: 24 ÷ 7 = 3 3/7, 24 ÷ 5 = 4 4/5, 24 ÷ 11 = 2 2/11. The digits of that mixed number tell you which of the remaining numbers to use.

How to spot a fraction puzzle quickly

  1. Spend ten seconds on factor pairs and working backwards (the methods in the Target 24 strategy guide). If nothing works, suspect a fraction.
  2. Repeated awkward numbers (two 7s, two 11s, two 13s) point to Trick 2.
  3. A 1 next to numbers that nearly cancel (like 3 and 4, 5 and 6) points to Trick 1.
  4. Compute 24 ÷ n for each number. A clean quotient (24 ÷ 8 = 3) suggests Trick 1; a mixed number (24 ÷ 7 = 3 3/7) suggests Trick 2.

Practise them

Cover the solutions above and try each set from scratch. In BRINXO's Number Forge, the fifth puzzle of every round is drawn from the hard pool, where puzzles with only one or two solutions — including some of these — appear. Hints are there if you need them, at a cost of 40 points each.